Annick Goutal Ninfeo Mio

The Big Cheese and I like wine.  We’re volume consumers, buying it by the case and drinking it with lunch and dinner, and our price point is around $10 a bottle ($7 on sale.)  If someone serves me a glass of something better I enjoy it, but my palate isn’t sophisticated enough, at least at this point, to be able to tell the difference.

But I don’t begrudge anyone their pricier bottles of wine, because I assume it’s providing them with a corresponding amount of pleasure.  When conversation on here and elsewhere drifts toward guilt about how much we spend on the frivolity of perfume, and how we already have more than we could wear in a lifetime, I shrug.  Perfume, ounce for ounce, still provides me with the great sybaritic pleasure in my life.  At the start (or the end) of a miserable January day, is there anything more wonderful than the smell of Serge Lutens’ Fleurs d’Oranger?  What could possibly make a perfumista happier in the moment than a whiff of one’s sillage of Timbuktu, or Shalimar, or Vetiver Tonka, or (name your poison, or Poison, here)?

Annick Goutal‘s latest release, Ninfeo Mio, is inspired by and named after the Gardens of Ninfa in Italy, about 40 miles southeast of Rome, and if you’d like to break your own heart right now, here’s a link to some pictures.  (Has anyone been there?  Is it that spectacular in person?)  The notes are Italian lemon, citron, petitgrain, bitter orange, galbanum, lentisque, conifers, lavender, fig leaf, and lemon tree (as interpreted by me from the press kit), and it was done by Isabelle Doyen.

Ninfeo Mio opens on a bright, citrusy, slightly peppery burst that smells very Goutal to me, so you sort of know who you’re sniffing, and on a cold January day it’s a smell of such infinite cheer it brought a smile to my face.  If it stopped right there I’d still love it for its unadorned happiness, but it doesn’t.  It just keeps getting better.   There’s a green twist of galbanum that is perfectly sharp – astringent but not too bitter – overlaying a woody, herbaceous middle (lentisque, or lentisc, which smells woody/resiny to me); the lavender is very subtle and I wouldn’t have guessed it.  If I hadn’t already loved it, the fig would have cinched the deal.  The galbanum becomes enveloped in a really interesting sweet/milky note, which I assume must have something to do with the fig.  The drydown is spectacular, a woody, leafy, musky/resin base with fig and another note that smells, weirdly, like green mangoes to me.   (Here’s a link to Octavian’s review, where he discusses the scent in more interesting technical detail than I’ll ever manage, he mentions lactones and the smell of mango leaf oil, among other things.)   As the fragrance dries down it deepens and becomes more complex, and it’s pretty robust for a Goutal, with good lasting power.

I don’t have any other scent just like this, and the only one I can think of that is vaguely comparable is Hermes’ Un Jardin Sur Le Nil.  But they don’t really smell alike, any more than two rose scents do – Sur Le Nil is more bitter, dry and peppery (and much as I try to love it, there’s something in there that starts to bug me after a couple of hours.)   Sur Le Nil also smells, for lack of a better term, more “perfume-y” – it smells more like a Hermes-inflected statement about a place via perfume, whereas Ninfeo Mio smells, accurately or not, more like the essence-notes of the place itself.

Grain de Musc once categorized many AG scents (in general terms) as either more sophisticated “mother” scents, like Passion, or more lighthearted “daughter” scents like Camille. It was an idea that resonated with me.  I’m now going to climb out on a limb and suggest that Ninfeo Mio bridges that gap, growing up as it progresses.  While the top notes are full of youthful exuberance (that aha! moment when you see something that delights) there’s a woody/herbaceous dryness throughout and a drydown that is rich and sophisticated and fully adult.

In terms of feel, I’d place this between Mandragore and the original Hadrien, probably, although Ninfeo Mio is rounder and more complex and certainly heavier (and they all smell quite different) – and I should note that, having tried it as many as three times in one day, there’s a faint but definite urinous note on my skin after the top notes fade, boxwoody would be the more delicate term, that bothers me not one bit, it fits in with the herbaceous-woody aspect of the scent.  But if you have trouble with that sort of thing, particularly in Mandragore, I’d be cautious about buying this unsniffed.  Me, I’m delighted that one of my favorite “wearable” houses made a scent with fig in it.

The bottle is frosted glass, like Mandragore, in a pale gray-green that is supposed to evoke the leaves of the garden reflected in the Ninfeo river.  It appears either light sea-glass green or grayish depending on the light, and it’s lovely.  It’s available in the round bottle in 50ml and 100ml, and the square in 100ml.  The bottle selection should give a hint: I’d define this as unisex, in the same way that Mandragore and Hadrien are unisex, although the drydown is richer and sweeter.

If you’re not a fan of the line, Ninfeo Mio probably isn’t going to convert you – it retains what I think of as the quintessential Annick Goutal charm, certainly more so than Les Orientalistes (which I liked very much) or Un Matin d’Orage (which … I didn’t.)  But if you like some of the “classic” AGs, particularly the citrusy/aromatic ones, or if like me you can’t get enough fig in your world, this would be worth investigating.  The scent is supposed to be released in the US in February.  If you’re curious about it I’d suggest calling Tom at the Annick Goutal counter at Bergdorf in NYC, I think he gets things in on the early side, and he’s great to deal with.

For another perspective on this scent, be sure to check out Robin’s review on Now Smell This today – she’s another fig fan, and she liked it too.

Disclosure (which we’re supposed to do now under the new FTC rules, more about that on Wednesday):  I received my preview bottle from the US distributor for Annick Goutal.

  • Lee says:

    Garden is beautiful. Perfume sounds beautiful. Name, for Spanish speakers, does sound bad. Awkward at best. Just plain old Ninfa would’ve been better.

    I know I’m simply paraphrasing what’s already been said, but whaddayawant – originality?

    Love ya.

    • March says:

      Ninfa would have been lovely. I have, I think the same issue — “feo” makes me think of ugly. And it’s a mouthful.

  • Robin R. says:

    Make that :d

  • Robin R. says:

    By the way, I must commend you on the ad on the left of my screen: the one that says “I went from THIS to THIS” with the Before and After pics. Yiiiii on the After. :-\”

    • March says:

      I must have some unbelievable ad-blocker ware on here, I almost never see any ads. /:)

      • Robin R. says:

        You don’t know what you’re missing.

        • March says:

          Clearly. Sometimes I look at this site on the husband’s computer and things pop out at me. (BTW nothing is SUPPOSED to do that, and I hired someone to try to find the rogue code, but we didn’t.)

          • Robin R. says:

            Darn it, March. Today the icky Before (pot belly, man boobs) and yummy After (six-pack, pecs of steel) shots are gone, and all there is to look at is a big smile full of bleached-white teeth with “I CURED MY YELLOW TEETH” on top. Woe is me. >:p

  • violetnoir says:

    I am very late to the game today, but I can’t wait to test this! I love AG fragrances.

    Hugs and love!

  • Linda says:

    What a fun review! I love the parallel between wine and perfume, because I’ve been pondering the parallel between perfume and liquors.

    • March says:

      At our last perfume party one of the attendees made drinks with scented liqueurs inspired by various perfumes, which was lovely.

  • Shelley says:

    Well, now, I would be one of those enticed by galbanum, leery of fig…but I am very aware that the whole is more than the parts in the sum. (um, was that tangled? /:) ) All in all, certainly one I am flagging to wrap my nose around when I have the opportunity.

    Sometimes, I just put scents in a “happy place” category. There are many paths there…just as there are many gardens that make me happy…but if I have landed there, boom, gets the label. Very subjective, YMMV, but there’s something about the garden reference that put me in that mindspace.

    • March says:

      I’d say (as Robin did) that this is more a woodsy fragrance with fig than a “fig” fragrance. I wouldn’t be surprised if it comes to your neck of the woods sooner rather than later. And yes, it’s a very nice garden-type fragrance.

  • Musette says:

    Okay, I’m probably going to Hell for this one but: my 90000 year old pop just moved in with us, bless his heart. Therefore, all ‘boxwood’ scents are now png, thankyewverymuch. I get enough ‘boxwood’ as it is!b-(

    xoxo >-)

  • cathleen56 says:

    How funny! Mr. 56 and I are the same kind of wine drinkers, minus the lunch part usually. There are a lot of very nice wines in that range.

    And even funnier, I had the same instinct today to put on something citrusy and bright to counteract the winter cold/dark, demise of Christmas tree, etc. For me, it was Diorella on one arm, AG Eau de Sud on the other. They are really very similar.

    • March says:

      It’s that kind of weather, isn’t it? Eau de Sud would be perfect for that (I’d likely go with Chevrefuille…)

      There are a lot of drinkable wines in that range for sure, at least by my standards. 🙂

  • ScentRed says:

    OMG I so want to try this. Lord knows when this will hit in Canada, though…:((

  • sweetlife says:

    As I just said over on NST — hooray! And this from you, who are not (if I remember correctly) so fond of galbanum…?

    Remembering D’s article, I think this one would go in the Daddy/unisex cologne category. Though you make it sound like it definitely crosses over into something more feminine as well.

    I was just thinking this morning about how I’ve failed to get really excited about many new launches lately, even the ones I’ve been wearing. 😕 But this really cheers me up somehow. I love Goutal.

    • March says:

      Galbanum I can take in reasonable doses, and not as the starring note. It’s not a note I dislike on its own (like rose) but man, it is easily overwhelming to me! Headache-inducing.

      If you love Goutal and you have any fondness for fig, this may be a winner.

  • Robin says:

    I feel like I should sit down & try all the Goutals again. I would not have recognized this as a Goutal at all, and I see so little link between the newer scents and the older ones, although this one does have some link with Mandragore. Regardless, Camille Goutal & Isabelle Doyen are doing a fantastic job…AG is rising in my estimation all the time.

    • March says:

      Don’t try all the Goutals again, because what if reformulations compared to what you remember make you sad? I hear this is true of Hadrien…. truly, though, the opening bits didn’t make you think Annick? I thought all that citrus smelled very Annick…. the rest of it, though, was different.

      • Robin says:

        No, really it made me think of Hermes Eau d’Orange Verte right away. If I didn’t know who made it, would never have guessed. But you’re right, I should certainly not get new samples!

        • March says:

          That is SO interesting. Okay then it is way sweeter on me than on you. Orange Verte is stunningly bitter on me, I find it bracing but wouldn’t necessarily wear it.

  • March says:

    Hah. Somehow the AGs seem very much not you, although I don’t even know what I mean by that. I assume they’d all last about nine seconds on Louise. I will say I think this one has surprising tenacity for the line.

    • Louise says:

      Hmmm… a Goutal with tenacity…very interesting 😕 I do like to layer the Encens Flaboyant with other ‘fumes, and it sticks-as do the richer florals, though I don’t care much for them /:)

    • Melissa says:

      I do know what you mean by that. I think that I would have to bath in most of them to make them stick around. But Un Matin d’Orage is intriguing and maybe I’ve just been seduced by the garden pictures, 😡 but I want to try this one.

  • Melissa says:

    I haven’t spent enough time with the Goutals to find one that I love. The Les Orientalistes line was nice, but not great. I keep flirting with Un Matin d’Orage but I haven’t yet fallen in love. This is pretty surprising to me, given its aquatic floral bent. (I also like L’Artisan Fleur de Liane, so maybe not so surprising).

    So, another Goutal to tease and intrigue me? Light boxwood notes don’t bother me and the development sounds fascinating. I was very interested when I read Octavian’s review and knowing that you like it just doubles my anticipation.

  • Silviafunkly says:

    Something else to look out for, thanks March. Ninfea in Italian is the word for water lily (here it has a different meaning, a ninfeo is a temple dedicated to a nymph) but the assonance would have been enough for me to dismiss it as a watery pond flower thingy, how wrong !

    • March says:

      Oh, that’s very interesting! It would be too bad if people skipped this one because they knew enough Italian to think it would be an aquatic/lily scent.

  • DinaC says:

    Very excited to try this one. Loved the way you described it, March, and right now in freezing January, gardens near Rome sound really nice. Since I’m one of the people who really likes galbanum and fig, I’m interested in this…another reason to look forward to February!

    • March says:

      Robin points out that she’d characterize this as a woody citrus with fig, as opposed to a fig scent with woods/citrus. She liked it a lot too.

  • Fiordiligi says:

    A lovely, lyrical review – thank you, March – but I’m not an AG fan, even though I’ve tried.

    We are big wine fans too – don’t you think that wine and perfume fans are often one and the same? I think this is why Mr F is also very interested in fragrance.

    I haven’t been to those gardens but am sure they are fantastic, like everything about Italy….sigh.

    • March says:

      Certainly there’s some overlap — I know several perfume nuts who are also wine fans and/or foodies. For awhile there the Cheese was getting more serious about his wine but (this is an entirely different discussion suitable for elsewhere) I think at some point he decided he wasn’t interested, the culture (?) didn’t appeal to him? So that was that; back to the $8 bottles of plonk. 😉

      And I don’t drink much red wine, it tends to give me a headache, but all close friends at a dinner table are used to me sniffing their wine…

      • Robin R. says:

        It’s the histamines in the red wine, M. If you really want to enjoy a special bottle along with your friends, you might try popping an antihistamine first. For lots of people, it works like a charm.

        P.S. For me, the wine/fragrance connection runs deep. There are so many parallels: the notes themselves (a chardonnay can smell of acacia flowers and peach; a gewurztraminer, of tea rose and grapefruit; a cabernet of cassis and cedar; a Chateauneuf du Pape of raspberries and violets), and the way they’re appreciated and described — top notes, middle notes, finish, length, complexity, depth, concentration, harmony, balance — are very similar. Both are intensely sybaritic and cerebral pleasures. I’ve been a professional wine writer and judge for nearly twenty years, and that’s no coincidence. 😉

        • March says:

          Hah, but then I’d be loaded with antihistamines (which make me spectacularly sleepy) and wine! |-)

          I don’t think I’ve ever used that emoticon before….

          See, you talk wine like a pro!

          • Robin R. says:

            Yeah, you wouldn’t want to do a face plant in the mashed potatoes. :-j

          • March says:

            You know what’s funny? I get these in my inbox and I try to think what the comment’s in response to. I forgot this one until I came to look for it!

          • Robin R. says:

            No kiddin’? I assumed the comment we’re responding to shows up along with ours.

            That must make for some interesting non sequiturs.

          • March says:

            Nope, it’s just the comment. Sometimes I can immediately know what it’s in response to. Sometimes I think: mashed potatoes? 🙂

        • carter says:

          That’s a great tip! And I agree that there are many parallels between wine and perfume.

          • Robin R. says:

            Glad you like it, Carter. I’ve gotten a whole ton of wardrobe ideas from you from the fashion-y piece here on PP a while back, so it’s kind of nice to be able to reciprocate in a teensy way. :)>-

  • Patty says:

    I live near the Ninfa garden and it is indeed a wonderful place.
    So, definitely a must-try for me, although I don’t really like the name. I would have just called it Ninfa.

    • March says:

      Could you clarify? Is the river itself called the Ninfeo and the garden called the Ninfa? The name “Ninfa” I like better too but I’m sure AG had their reasons.

      • Patty says:

        I’ve just checked on the website and it’s how I remembered: the river name is Ninfa, not Ninfeo (it’s said below a photo in the gallery, il fiume Ninfa, the river Ninfa).
        Ninfa is actually the name of the medieval town where the garden is located and there are only ruins of it nowadays. We call it Giardini di Ninfa which can be literally translated into Ninfa Gardens.
        I think Ninfa would sound too feminine for a unisex perfume?

        • March says:

          Okay, so fully displaying my ignorance — then is “ninfeo” nonsensical in Italian? Is it the way it gets conjugated if you use “mio” (which is “mine,” right?) Is this some made-up Italian? I agree that one motivation might be “Ninfa” sounds too femme, but it’s a pretty word, yes?

          • Silviafunkly says:

            As far as I know in Italian a Ninfeo is a temple dedicated to a nymph, as often found in classically inspired landscape gardens

          • March says:

            Well, that makes sense. I double checked and in their PR piece they refer to the river as the “Ninfeo” so I was extra confused, as everything I’ve found online says Ninfa.

  • This was the Goutal “mommy/daddy/daughter” post: http://graindemusc.blogspot.com/2009/08/annick-goutal-songes-dreams-of-heated.html

    I discovered Ninfeo Mio in Isabelle’s lab and she asked me not to write about it yet. Then life happened and I kind of missed the launch. The weather here in Paris doesn’t quite lend itself to garden-like fragrances but I’ll need to go back to the shops to test this, from my first impressions it was lovely and, you’re right, in a similar line with Mandragore.

    • March says:

      Thanks so much, I’ll add it to the post — I thought it was you (or maybe Angela at NST.) I pawed through your Isabelle Doyen interview and a couple other places and couldn’t find it.

      Agh, the weather there sounds just awful. Of course you’re still in Paris. 😉

  • Klara says:

    Lovely review, cannot wait to try it. I received a sample of Grand Amour a few days ago and I never thought I’d like it but it’s beautiful. Oh, and I think that the “categoriaztion” of Goutals was done over at graindemusc.

    • March says:

      Yep, she chimed in below, thanks! C’mon, Grand Amour is a GREAT scent! I have a teeny bottle I assume from some kind of promo and it’s so lovely.

  • hongkongmom says:

    i have just ordered amber fetich and myrrhe from fragrance net….i like all AN’s but LOVE some of them…am VERY keen to try this one, when the weather lightens a bit!:)

    • March says:

      Les Orientalistes were so interesting, I liked all of them and I loved the Amber, which surprised me. Please give Ninfeo a whirl if and when you see it.

  • Francesca says:

    My feelings about Goutal are similar to the ones I have about Powell/Pressberger (the Archers) movies: the ones I love, I love, and the ones I don’t love…I HATE.
    But I have to give this new one a chance.

    • March says:

      It’s interestingly fruity for a Goutal (although not overly sweet.) And your comment is interesting … I don’t think of them in terms of love/hate — more wear/don’t wear. (I only hate a couple.) 🙂 I’m thinking the fig will be a big factor in this one.

  • Scent HIve says:

    You had me until Boxwood. We had some Boxwood outside our old house and I could not figure out why our house smelled like cat pee. It was the Boxwood all along.

    Otherwise, this sounds heavenly. I’ll wait long enough to try it in hopes that the Boxwood/cat pee association will be forgotten. [-o< Trish

    • March says:

      Do wait and try it! :d I am not a huge fan of boxwood if that’s ALL I get (like many folks, I get mostly boxwood or pee from certain grapefruit scents.) I just felt honor-bound to note it because after sniffing so closely and for so long at my arm, I thought, hey, I know that smell!

      • Robin R. says:

        I’m almost positive there’s boxwood in DelRae Amoureuse, which I love to the heavens. Oh, wait a sec, it’s box tree, not boxwood. Is there a difference? 😐

        • March says:

          As far as I know, boxwood and box tree (both buxus?) are the same, but I don’t recall the notes of Amoureuse at all!

          • cathleen56 says:

            There’s something called Sweet Box (there’s a big bed of it at Brookside Gardens, by the way) that smells just divine. And then there’s boxwood (only some varieties, apparently) which smells like, well, cat pee. I once had a landlord who accused me of letting my cat stink up the place while all along it was just those %^*%(%^ boxwoods.

            Sweet Box — that would be a good name for a perfume. Maybe paired up in a holiday gift set with Bois de Matin? 😕

          • March says:

            … now that is just naughty.

            There seem to be several varieties of box, I am not sure about all the variations. I think whatever we grow in the states grows faster and is different than European.

      • Scent HIve says:

        Oh no, you saved me an impulse purchase March! Will make sure I spend plenty of time with this one before I splurge 🙂

        ~T

  • Robin R. says:

    P.S. That picture gallery of the gardens made me swoon. Thanks for the eye candy.

    • March says:

      I know, I know. If I’d known about those gardens I’d have tried to visit when I was in Rome a couple years ago. :-w

      • Robin R. says:

        Me, too. Weird. I swear I’ve never seen anything about them in all the dozens of Rough Guides and Lonely Planets I’ve read. Might even have been within a half hour’s detour of ’em on the way down to Naples. Bummer. #-o

  • Robin R. says:

    Ah, March. Great writing, and I’d be head over heels with this new AG as you’ve described it, except for that one @&%$! deal-buster. I’m one of Those People who just don’t “get” Mandragore. Well, actually, I do get it, in the sense that I’m not confused by it; I just don’t enjoy life when it’s in my nostrils. Maybe I’ve got a foot in and a foot out of the Annick Goutal camp. I think I do, actually. I still think I want to give this one a once-around-the-block (and isn’t that a great Badly Drawn Boy tune besides?) because despite that urinous note Ninfeo Mio sounds enchanting. The way you describe the galbanum note is enough to get my little motor purring. We shall see. ;;)

    • March says:

      Lots of people don’t adore Mandragore, although let me hasten to add in case I was unclear that this doesn’t smell LIKE Mandragore. I just indulged in my usual mental exercise of trying to decide what else in the line it was most similar too in terms of feel. And the scent isn’t unsophisticated or overtly “virtual-reality” like, for instance, some of the CBIHPs. As you can tell I think it’s very nice!