Frederic Malle is a house that I do really like, as a matter of fact it is my second favorite of the houses formerly known as “niche” (you can’t be niche and owned by a giant corporation, which seems to be the eventual fate, if not the goal, of most “niche” houses.) Looking through my cupboard I do have at least small ones of French Lover, Music for a While, L’Eau D’Hiver, and Musc Ravageur and if I didn’t need to pay for insurance or food, I would have a big bottle of The Night. Not all of them knock it out of the park mind you. I didn’t care for Dans Tes Bras and as far as I was concerned Outrageous! wasn’t. March writing about Uncut Gem (and the new, upcoming one) made me think that I should saunter over to the Malle boutique, just a few blocks this way and a few that from my office. It’s hot, however, and I am lazy. If I walked I’d get all schvitzy or I’d have to get the car out and find parking and the dog ate my homework and soooo..
I ordered samples from Surrender to Chance. There’s something to be said for convenience. All of these were previously reviewed here on the Posse, so I will be referring to (and linking, so feel free to go back and read) those reviews.
Patty really liked Synthetic Jungle. She liked that it was a take on the big green perfumes of the 70’s but sort of with the big grasping tendrils clipped down. I have to write that I kind of felt the opposite- I love the big, green, grassy, revenge-of-the-lawn opening (“mow me, will you; well I am going to pelt you with wet clippings until you beg for mercy!!) but I think it too quickly goes into a shy lily of the valley. It’s lovely mind you, just not necessary in my life. If someone knows one that’s available today that’s one of those big green monsters please mention it in the comments. Or if the Private Collection available today is as large-and-in-charge as the one Patty mentions from back in the day, I could cheerfully hang with that. I just don’t want another L’Interdit situation here..
Conversely. Le Parfume De Therese Patty hated. HATED. I can’t write that I Capital H hated it, but I was certainly indifferent unto disliking to it. It opened on me with an interesting slightly minty-cool jasmine, then went through a phase where it was just sort of standard powdery perfume. Then big melon came in after a hearty workout, kicked off the Adidas and decided to steal the remote from Ms. Jasmine and hog all the snacks. Mr. Melon is a boorish sort, averse to showering after his exercise (or changing his socks) and apparently a little gassy. Miss Jasmine keeps trying to throw baby powder over big melon (try baking soda, dear, or a net) but to no avail. I can almost see where this would work on someone else. That someone is certainly not, however, me.
As for Uncut Gem, March loved it and I will say “what she said.” I will add that I can understand how someone at first application could just sort of roll their eyes and think “department store”- it does kind of riff on that vibe. It sort of reminds me a bit in the opening of some Chanel I smelled (and maybe had) back in the day: the play between warm ginger and nutmeg and cool citrus and sweet angelica is both kind of retro and yet completely modern. I can’t write that it does anything that’s going to really surprise but it will delight- the vetiver/leather/musk is very civilized and yes, somewhat “Masculine” but not in any way that should put off ladies from grabbing it and enjoying it. This is good breeding and quiet good taste in a bottle: a Rolex, but in stainless steel. Silver that’s inherited. A lovingly kept 280SL rather than a flashy AMG. It has the perfection of a really well tailored suit: you can buy Armani off the rack but you will still look lumpy next to the guy who went to the tailor downtown and had 3 or 4 fittings. That guy will look like Cary Grant in “North by Northwest”, who was supremely dapper whether lounging at the Oak Room or evading a murderous crop duster. And as for the scent’s “masculinity” I can see the ladies here using this, with that Kate Hepburn in pants (or Jennifer O’Neill in a man’s button-down) insouciance. Were I a married lady I would buy this for my husband, but filch from it ruthlessly.
Uncut Gem is $295 for 50ML, $455 for 100, Therese is $395 for 100ML, and Jungle is $225 for 50ML, $340 for 100 at the usual suspects (of course I’d love the priciest one..). My samples, as mentioned were from Surrender to Chance.
Photos: Pexels, Wikimedia Commons and my iPhone
Parfum de Therese is the only Malle I own. It reminds of Femme, one of my favourite fragrances. I also really like Iris Poudre and Bigarade Concentree, but only have samples of those.
Have you tried Green Spell? It’s a great green fragrance with a wonderful tomato leaf note.
L’Eau d’Hiver is my favorite Malle. I have not tried Uncut Gem but the reviews say it comes off masculine so it hasn’t been a priority. While I would not purchase Le Parfum de Therese, I do think its rose note is really lovely. And as for Synthetic Jungle, while not being quite believable as a “jungle” scent, it is I think something to be commended. Unique, bold, even aggressively so–The Hulk on my perfume shelf. I would recommend Sisley Eau de Campagne as a vintage big green.
I’ll have to look up that Sisley. L’Eau d’Hiver is one that I have actually gone through a couple of bottles. It’s gorgeous, and I don’t think it gets a lot of love.
I really appreciate that you bring up the topic of F. Malle parfumes because they are worth it. I like Synthetic Jungle but there are other green perfumes out there that I like more (Patricia de Nicolai’s Weekend in Normandy, Chanel Cristalle Eau Vert, Jacomo Silences and the swampy Serpentine by Comme des Garcons). Parfum de Therese reminds me of Diorissimo and that one is a big like for me.
Of all the F. Malle perfumes I had Noir Epices, Dans tes Bras, Eau de Magnolia and Rose & Cuir in travel sizes and I have a bottle of Superstitious. I still have to try Uncut Gem, your thoughts on it are very intriguing.
Thanks! I appreciate that!
I really like Malle. Even the ones that I personally don’t care for at least have a point of view. So many houses seem to do scents via commitee or focus groups. I mean, I’m sure they mean these to sell, but they realise that they don’t have to be liked by almost everyone but really loved by none.
Synthetic Jungle is kinda nice, but that’s it. I do love Musc Ravageur and Dans Tes Bras. Your post reminded me that I wanted to get a large decant of Carnal Flower. Even if it were cheaper, I don’t want a full bottle. Now, Uncut Gem sounds great. I had been wondering if I should try it especially since the perfumer is Maurice Roucel. Thanks to you and March, I will. I could not care less if it’s called masculine.
I like SJ (See below) but have enough of LotV around that that ground is well trod. I have been told that Carnal Flower is actually best in the body cream. Highly scented and much cheaper that the juice.
Good to know on Carnal Flower. Thanks. I have gradually gotten into body creams, though I doubt I’ll ever use it regularly. I’m too lazy and never needed it, but I find I do like the perfumed effect of a good scented body cream instead of spray perfume.
I’m not a big body cream person since I don’t (or didn’t) have dry skin. But I am told that CF is a good way to get the sent without spending the rent AND the food bill to do so.
Nice reviews, Tom! I own a bottle of Synthetic Jungle. That lovely green-ness is my cup of tea. I remember reading about and sampling Therese back in 2008 when I first read The Guide, but I can’t remember what I thought of it. As a novice perfumista I’m sure it was a scented Blur to me. I still haven’t sniffed Uncut Gem. I’m in those lazy, hazy, crazy days of summer I guess.
Good for you on Synthetic Jungle- if I owned one I think I would go through it in about six days just to smell that opening. Not that I disliked the rest, far from it. But that opening blast of green? Oh you kid!
Le sigh… that Cary Grant…
They don’t make them like that anymore, and he has so far avoided the Jennifer Love Hewitt/Audrey Hepburn treatment. So far:
https://variety.com/2022/tv/news/cary-grant-biopic-archie-jason-isaacs-1235335717/
Sigh. Malles are, even if you don’t like certain ones, always worth testing. And I so appreciate the 10ml travel size which, while still pricey, is do-able. I do love Therese and it does melon, jasmine and whathaveyou on me all discernibly. A custom made suit — I would love a YSL Le Smoking — even only the jacket. A well-cut suit is a thing of beauty.
Yes, that’s what I like about that house. Even if I don’t like them personally, they are never just phoning it in.
My dad travelled for work and had suits made for him in Hong Kong. You had to pick your fabric carefully, because if you asked for hot pink astroturf, you’d get hot pink astroturf, but the tailoring and attention to detail was flwaless, and they could replicate anything.
My brother and sil lived in HK for many years and were always in bespoke clothing – and it was sheer perfection (and cheap as chips).
I recently saw a GORGEOUS man – in an ill-fitting suit – and it was heartbreaking. Even more heartbreaking was the fact that he had NO idea. None.
Le sigh.
To some it just doesn’t matter. Of course, if they had one..
Then there’s the downside that you can never gain an ounce lest your vest can’t be buttoned and the houndstooth starts to get wavy lines..
Ha, vindication! Apparently I was not in agreement with many (most?) other people writing about Uncut Gem. I’m glad you felt like I did! I won’t be running out for a bottle, but I’d cheerfully wear it. Maybe people were unhappy it wasn’t more masculine/avant garde but I thought it was lovely and wearable without being dull. I like your idea of “the perfection of a really well tailored suit.”
Yeah, I don’t NEED it, but if it showed up in my Xmas stocking I’d be happy. I think some people just won’t settle for anything less than fireworks, and this isn’t it. Neither is French Lover, but I love and own that one.
French Lover I remember liking very much as well; it dawned on me that maaaaybe part of what I appreciate so much about Uncut Gem is it doesn’t have whatever that man-wood (heh) chemical is in many current men’s fragrances that smells like Satan’s pencil to me and lasts an eternity.
I know which pencil you mean, Malle uses (if he uses at all) the full-on Faber No 2 made of real wood. No wood pulp and glue.
Satan’s Pencil the double entrendre! My brain immediately went to Saran’s Whiffy Willy
Laughed out loud!
I feel vindicated, too! This one reminds me of Geranium pour Monsieur, which is on the knife edge of the traditional gender spectrum. GpM, on a man, makes me want to gnaw his arm – or his neck (if it’s the right man) but smells divine on a woman, as well.
Yep, love GpM! But I’d wear it too…
Well now I am looking for it and it’s not at the ususal suspects. Is is D/C? Is it just now “Monsieur?”
GpM I forgot about. Loved it, but for some reason never bought. Oh wait, I remember. I didn’t want to smell great living under an overpass..
LOL! But you would’ve had THE CHICEST BOX! in the neighborhood!
Hey Tom,
Malle stood for excellence for me when first falling down the rabbit hole, even though not all were to my taste. I remember there being two full standing cubicles that you could get in for the experience of testing a fragrance. It was out of this world.
The one I have collected a few different era bottles of is Musc Ravageur. So bloody good.
Portia xx
Oh I remember those booths! I thought them kind of silly at the time. MR is gorgeous- I popped for the full bottle on that one. Not a spikey as MKK, but I love it. May go put some on now..
Sorry (ok not) for butting in but I’ve seen the comparisons of MKK (now KK WTAF!) & MR & just don’t sniff them as fraternal, cousinal or even of the same genre.
Maybe I’m anosmic to some, especially huge musk molecule they share, after all I did love layering MKK with Poison.
To me MR is far more Lutens with its spices & sweet touch than MKK’s funky rose & sourness.
If anyone has both please can you do a side by side?
I did a side by side a decade ago, when MKK was still MKK. MR was a gentle very soft skin scent on me — nothing remotely ravageur. Just sort of ‘nice’. No comparison.
Yeah I don’t think it’s much ravageur either.
I’ll do some searching
alityke – just an FYI: we WANT you to ‘butt in’ – that’s the whole point of this blog!
Alas, I gotz NOTHIN’ on these two – I hate them both! Alas. Well…. ‘Hate’ (with a CAPITAL H) is a tad strong – but I am not a fan. Alas
Yes!! I love “butting in”|!” I call it “conversation” and welcome it!
MKK is definitely more musky- a lot more. Closer to the funk of Kieh’s but much smoother and more expensive smelling- as if the Hippie Kiehl’s started selling the Macrame Art at 7 figure prices and upgraded accordingly. MR is much more creamy and almost buttery smooth, with an almost custard note to it that reminds me very much of Lutens Douce Amere.
I had a brain fart & sold my export bottle of MKK to pay No1 son’s rent. Regretted it ever since but he didn’t come home & has done rather well since
The prices for these fragrances are beyond outrageous. We did not realize how good we had it back on the day. Now, the bottom line is that everyone just wants your money. There isn’t
even any justification for the ridiculous prices and mostly everything is watered down. It is a very sad time for true fragrances lovers.
Remember when Serge Lutens came out and they were something like $59? And it was an outrage!? Oh for the days..
I’m simply priced out of these.