More Comfort Scents

Today´s post evolved from my most recent fragrance acquisition, a swap on MUA that (small world) turned out to be with a Gail, a blog regular. Gail shares my fondness for comfort scents and included several interesting things in her package, which got me headed in a new direction.

Yves Rocher Neonatura Cocoon – okay, I see what appeals. I really do. But this is two or three tiny baby steps too far in the direction of Angel to delight me – I really bring the patch out. It is, to be sure, a much quieter, more streamlined composition of chocolate, vanilla and patch, and any of you who love that cocoa-patch dynamic should check it out.

Dawn Spencer Hurwitz (DSH) – the focus of the rest of today´s post. The DSH line is enormous. How enormous? The reviews of her scents on MUA go on for 21 pages at 15 fragrances per page. You do the math; it´s crazy, right? Going on her website is so overwhelming I never end up ordering anything. The company´s based in Boulder, and a lot (all?) of the scents come with ancillary bath/body products. Thus, many of the scents are of the attractive-but-not-earth-shatteringly-complex type you might like in a body lotion. I can´t speak to the breadth of DSH styles – she does dupes and vintage type scents, and various “inspired by” fragrances. I have also read that she knows her way around roses.

To my nose, something she does really well is a particular style of comfort scent. Pick some combo of: woods, incense, vanilla or clean musk, spices, rice steam, subtle florals … you get the picture. Her gourmand, woods and spice scents have a wearable seamlessness to them. They are not particularly sweet, and they are not “foody” – even her highly popular Café Noir, while smelling very much of coffee, isn´t something you´d want to drink. The equally wonderful Cimabue, a riff on L’Artisan’s Safran Troublant, is chock full of spices, but you wouldn’t mistake it for something to eat. Anyhoo, here are some comfort scents from her line, which I am enjoying right now as chilly, blustery weather will not loosen its freaking grip in my neck of the (still leafless) woods…

Blond Suede. Bergamot, spice notes, violet, Bulgarian rose, jasmine, hay absolute, orris, amber, castoreum, honey, leather, sandalwood. There is exactly one review of this on MUA, and I ask you – where the heck are the other 85?!? This stuff is great. From the website: “While most leather scents are deep and overtly’ animalic’, Blond Suede is wonderfully light and subtly textured.” Blond Suede is a reasonable facsimile of suede; there´s that light buttery leather-goods note, and the faint tinge of pepper to give you the texture. But the beauty of the scent from my perspective is the other note that sneaks in a few minutes later — a dead ringer for the divine maple-hay-curry goodness of immortelle. I have no idea whether DSH was aiming for immortelle, or maybe it´s a trick of some combination of the honey, hay and spice notes, but why quibble about perfection? Blond Suede is, essentially, gentle spices, suede and immortelle – soft, velvety and comforting.

St. Valentine. Bergamot, nutmeg, Parma violet, Bulgarian rose, centifolia rose, raspberry, tea rose, amber, Bourbon vanilla, dark chocolate, French vanilla. This smells like a softer, incense-free, easier-to-wear version of S-Perfume´s 100% Love. Mostly chocolate, vanilla, roses and a pinch of violet. Having overdosed awhile ago on 100% Love, this wasn´t pure love for me, but the husband, two friends, and the girls adored it.

Mahjoun. Bitter almond, cardamom, cherry blossom, lavender, lemon, sweet orange, Bulgarian rose, fig, hazelnut, honey, nutmeg, orange blossom, sugar date, amber, Atlas cedarwood, cinnamon bark, clove bud, frankincense, sandalwood, myrrh. Comfort scent par excellence. I´d compare it to Chergui (okay, okay, minus Serge´s special je ne sais quoi sauce), only the drydown´s deeper and missing the honeyed amber sweetness of Chergui that sometimes makes me feel a bit ill. Much less sweet and smoother than you might gather from that list of notes; darkly spicy but restrained about it. Layers beautifully with …

Sienna. Cinnamon leaf, curry leaf, pink peppercorn, basmati, cinnamon bark, honey, white oak, civet, labdanum, leather, peru balsam, tolu balsam. This gets dissed as “not enough” on the boards, and I´d say that´s part of its charm. It´s a subtle scent, I grant you. It´s the level of subtlety you reach for when you want your scent to be discreet; the cinnamon is not blasting up your nose, and the rest is a faintly spicy resinous scent. Sometimes that is precisely what I want. Layers beautifully with Blond Suede, giving it a subtly sweet cinnamon/spice kick.

Having tried these, here is the list of ones I really want to try next: Chai Tea, Gingembre, Prana, Au Lait, Ceylon, Tamarind/Paprika, Lumiere, Poivre, Indochine, and Piment/Chocolate. Note the mellow, gourmand theme there. If you´ve tried any of those or any of the other DSH line and would like to comment, or add to my list, please do so.

On another subject: We (and you) do a fair amount of grumbling on this blog about how we wish fragrance came in smaller sizes. I was in Sephora recently when I noticed the limited edition set of Kenzo Amour bottles (below), which – come on! – are the cutest things – I think 3″ – 4″ tall? (Guessing.)  When looking for a photo on their website, I see they now have a two sections (airplane-friendly and petite) devoted to smaller sized bottles or bottle sets.

Granted, this is generally mass-market stuff — what is Sephora if not mass market? But I´d love a little bottle of the Omnia Crystalline, those Kenzos, and some others. I think this is a great marketing strategy by Sephora; on average their consumers are younger and less well-heeled than those at, say, Nordstrom, and they´re probably more likely to buy a $35 fragrance than a $70 one. Or they´ll do what I´d do – spend the $70 and get two fragrances. I also like the small bottles because they´re easy to throw in a purse or a travel bag. My (perhaps completely meritless) hope is other retailers notice the small bottles sell and try to work something similar out with their own inventory.

chai tea image: everythingcoffee-tea.com; Kenzo Amour, Sephora.com

0 0 votes
Article Rating
93 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Elle
18 years ago

Late, but had to chime in and say how much I love the scents in the Rouges series of her Beaux Arts line (which I think, in general, has a number of extremely lovely scents). She really does do roses beautifully and you’re right – has a way w/ gourmands. Au Lait is *so* not what I would have ever thought I’d like, but…I love it. Uber comforting. Layers well w/ Chai Tea. Also find Mahjoun, Piment et Chocolat, Marzipan and Cimabue to be extremely well done comfort scents. Have actually finished a bottle of PeC and had to repurchase – extraordinarily rare for me. Wore Tamarind/Paprika a great deal during December – seemed like an excellent holiday scent. She also does well w/ floral bouquets – Essenza dell’Ibisco, Giardini Segreti and Gelsomino are all lovely. I know you don’t love cedar, but, if you did, Hinoki is beyond brilliant and layers wonderfully w/ a variety of scents. Can’t believe I haven’t tried Blond Suede. Am off to place a sample order. I wish to God she’d get a good marketing person who would convince her to edit her line. Or just sell the Essence line somewhere separately – there are just TOO many and the quality is not comparable to her Beaux Arts scents. I think she’s a superb perfumer w/ tremendous potential, but puts out too many sketches/drafts side by side w/ her masterpieces. Confusing and diminishes the appreciation of the masterpieces.

Elle
18 years ago
Reply to  March

In the interest of full disclosure, I should say that I only wear Marzipan layered w/ sandalwood scents or w/ her Hinoki. 🙂 It’s a bit too sweet for me otherwise, but, still a great comfort scent. Marzipan is one of the very few sweets I enjoy eating and is one of my only great food memories from childhood, so that predisposes me to liking it in a scent. Yep, Fete Nouvelle is her interpretation of the Jour de Fete theme.

Debbie
18 years ago
Reply to  March

I LOOOOVE to eat marzipan! :@):@):@)

Debbie
18 years ago
Reply to  Elle

The Beaux Arts *are* completely separate from the Essences. The only real problem, as I see it, is that the essences contain both the masterpieces along with sketches and single notes. Beyond that, the whole thing is easily solved by taking one section at a time: look at just the Beaux Arts. Look at just the gourmands in the Essences, etc., and accept the fact that you won’t be sampling everything at once. Once I did that, it became very simple.

You know y’all have added *five* to my must-sample list, and I just placed a huge order. :-w 🙂

Louise
18 years ago

er, two.>:/

Louise
18 years ago
Reply to  March

I resemble that remark /:)

Admin
18 years ago

Agree on DSH — she does some types of scents really great, though I’m just not a fan of Cimabue and those, but love the pepper ones she does. But there are a whole raft of scents she does that are just… well, boring. 🙂

Deirdre
18 years ago

Having just been exposed to the world of decanting, I feel like my perfume universe just grew by leaps and bounds! As soon as my first batch arrives, my friends and I are holding a little smelling party. So here’s my question…at an appropriately appointed dinner, one cleanses the palate between courses. Is there something similar to do between different scents? I always heard after 3 different smells, your nose couldn’t tell the difference. Our perfume party is going to focus on Chanel’s Les Exclusifs. thanks!

Debbie
18 years ago
Reply to  Deirdre

Yes. The only chic perfume store that this town has ever had…wait, I’m starting to vent. Use coffee beans in mesh-net fabric, tied with a little ribbon on the top. If you smell these between scents, you will be amazed. I learned it at the above store.

Deirdre
18 years ago
Reply to  Debbie

Debbie, thanks so much! And your vents are always welcome. Our little scent club is going to work our way through the Perfume 101 and 201 suggestions. We’re so glad you guys are here!

thanks again!

Debbie
18 years ago
Reply to  Deirdre

What a fun club!!

Dusan
18 years ago

That Mahjoung (?) sounds delish – gotta work me some decant. My comfie scent lately has been Héritage – plush woods, spices and vanilla, yum!

Robin
18 years ago

I liked Mahjoun, and now I want to try Sienna. And Cafe Noir I had not even heard of, is it great?

But gosh, I can hardly stand to go to the DSH website — I just go into overload.

Debbie
18 years ago
Reply to  Robin

Yes, Cafe Noir is that great, assuming that you love coffee fragrances. It is dark coffee at the beginning (not the intense espresso in NM’s Cafe) and then goes into a sweetened coffee. No milk or cream in this one.

Debbie
18 years ago
Reply to  March

I confused them…I think. I think it was Ava Luxe I was describing.

Tigs / Erin
18 years ago

I have been lemming samples of Cimabue and Tamarind/Paprika for some time and I’ve been wanting to try that blasted Piment et Chocolat or whatever since Robin first reviewed it on NST many, many moons ago. The latter seems like what Piment Brulant should have been (even though I like PB a lot for what it is. Who doesn’t want to smell like a red bell pepper?) But then Patty said the P & C really was a chocolate fragrance, which has been confirmed by a number of other people, and the Tamarind didn’t sound Tamarindy enough, more like a spicy orange pomander and so I keep adding and removing the DSH from my wishlist at the Perfumed Court. Clearly, one of these days I need to bite the bullet and order these dern things…

18 years ago

We’re all about the chilly gray here in NYC today, I’m with you on the comfort scents. But, it won’t be DSH. I got about 7 or 8 in a swap & even though they were chock full of notes that should have worked for me, they all hit me wrong, made me sneeze &/or scrub. I think that line is just not for me.

Smaller bottles … yes. Yes, yes, yes. Please, yes. Nice little 15 ml bottles or even smaller. Even at premium prices, prices that come out to more per ml than if I got the grande 100 ml size. Please. Small, cute, easy to travel with, use up-able, pretty little bottles. Thanx.

18 years ago

:”>

18 years ago
Reply to  Gail S

Huh? Don’t know what the heck happened there – was supposed to be a blushing emoticon for Rosarita up there!

Musette
18 years ago
Reply to  March

I thing they’re just cranky today – I was trying to use the little cheery one (the one to the right of the crying one) but Grinner decided he was Da Man….and barged his big, toothy self right on in there.

Oh, well. Can’t fight the Emoticons

:d/

sweetlife
18 years ago

Hey, look at that — a review of Cimabue right there in the comments along with your other delicious dishes on DSH, March. And I am a (dark) rose lover, so that Inner Sanctum sounds pretty good, too. The name makes me want to giggle, though…

Thanks so much for the round up, it makes it seem possible…and I do love a small, affordable bottle. Right on.

Lee
18 years ago
Reply to  sweetlife

Sounds like Inner Sanctum’s right up your alley.;))

sweetlife
18 years ago
Reply to  Lee

:))

Debbie
18 years ago

I forgot to mention that some of them come with the option of a fixative. I ordered one with that in hopes that it will last longer on the skin. The extra couple of bucks would be worth it. Just a thought if that’s an issue…

rosarita
18 years ago
Reply to  Debbie

The Inner Sanctum bottle I have is the one w/a fixative and one spray lasts 10+ hours. And I love the smaller bottle oprion, too.

Dang, that carnation sounds wonderful! This post has me making up another sample order. 🙂

rosarita
18 years ago
Reply to  rosarita

*sigh* option, of course…

Debbie
18 years ago
Reply to  rosarita

I am so glad to hear that the fixative solves the problem! Great!
On the Oeillets Rouges, if you look on MUA, you’ll see a 4.8 rating (out of 5) with a 75 percent rebuy. I don’t know why my review isn’t there….will have to correct that. It is gorgeous. If you love carnation scents, you will love this. I’d love to hear what you come up with on your order, unless it’s so long the typing would give you carpal tunnel. She has a way of doing that to us. 😉

18 years ago
Reply to  March

:d/

Just thinking about carnations is cheery!

btw – my comfort scent is Joy. I’ve been wearing it so long I don’t even smell it anymore…I just know it’s there (does that make sense?) I use a sharp citrus bodywash/lotion underneath to cut it a bit, on days when my nerves are a little more frayed than normal…but ‘cut’ or not, it seems to be my default scent.

18 years ago
Reply to  Musette

Dang. I was hoping for this emoticon:d/ but it seems :d had other ideas…oh, well.

Musete
18 years ago
Reply to  Musette

okay – never mind on the emoticons.

Lee
18 years ago
Reply to  March

He bugs me. I like Mr. Dribble. Never used him. =p~ Til now.

Lee
18 years ago
Reply to  March

No he’s not.[-x

Louise
18 years ago
Reply to  Lee

Stop bickering, you too! This is getting too narrow :-w

Louise
18 years ago
Reply to  March

Let’s seeeeeeee=d>

Musette
18 years ago
Reply to  Louise

You know I can’t resist, either :d/

(just so ya know, I’m trying for the little cheerful guy again – if that li’l grinner shows up, I’m going to smack him!)

Debbie
18 years ago

I agree that she has some the absolute best comfort scents. I just wish they lasted longer on me. I have to respray every two hours. Somewhere, I read that she said it was deliberate….that the experience of putting on a fragrance is something wonderful in itself. I wonder if she might have thought we should enjoy the topnotes more often than once every six hours. 🙂

I own Cimabue and Oeillets Rouges. The former is so complex; it is a happy, celebratory scent to me. Oeillets Rouges has carnation nailed, and it is pretty darned wonderful layered with Cimabue also. I have just put in a massive order: Scandal-type, Mahjoun, and Old School Musk. The Scandal-type is so wonderfully civety. I know you would love it. Mahjoun is so deep, I could drown in it. I love the fig note!! BTW, I am also a Chergui lover. Old School Musk has some incredible fresh green notes. I am lemming after Tamarind Paprika. I really did not expect to like this, but it was one of those glorious swap surprises. I have a bunch of samples coming too…can’t remember which.

For all of you who are overwhelmed by the DSH catalog, just jump in. Pick a category and order a few from it. Or use our impressions to help make a decision. They are pretty unique and wonderful, as long as you don’t mind respraying often. I also love the fact that we can get these in smaller sizes rather than the humongous 2-ouncers.

Debbie
18 years ago
Reply to  March

Sorry, don’t know. 🙁

rosarita
18 years ago

So many things to comment about, I’m stuttering already. First, the divine Gail, who nearly wiped out my wishlist w/a single swap package on MUA..:x Then, DSH, a slippery slope I finally gave in to over the winter. The big winner for me is Inner Sanctum, which you’d probably hate, M, but for other rose lovers is fabulous: deep, dark rose w/incense and woods, yum. Great tenacity and one of my most worn scents of the winter, I split a bottle with Roseinfo, another incredible MUAer who ended up giving me the whole bottle. (I feel very loved on MUA). Of the DSH samples I purchased, I also really liked Lumiere but it’s been so long since I tried it that I can’t remember what was great about it. To Maria, above, I sampled Hinoki but didn’t care for it, as it felt like a heavy-handed dupe attempt of CdG Kyoto. I’d like to do another sample order for some lighter, warm weather scents, the variety is amazing, and now I need to check out the sale! On the subject of smaller bottles, I also think the little Bulgaris from Sephora are adorable, and I’d like to put in a word for fragrance minis in general. I have quite a few. You get enough in a mini to really try out a scent, the bottles are very cute and they’re generally cheap; lots of times a mini is plenty, too. On the downside, they’re usually dabbers and not sprayers, so aren’t quite as purse friendly.

Lee
18 years ago

I can’t open that DSH door. I’m already swamped, dude.

Though like, you, I’m a comfort scent lover. Just eaten a hot cross bun (toasted, buttered) and sipping a chai after getting home from the briefest of brief meetings. My holiday starts in just over an hour (half-day off…) Wheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!

Lee
18 years ago
Reply to  March

And these hot cross buns are hot, I’m telling you…. Oh my!

Louise
18 years ago
Reply to  Lee

Home-made buns, are they? :))

Lee
18 years ago
Reply to  Louise

Nah… I was going to crack a wholly inappropriate bun related joke, but decided to refrain (delete it) at the last moment.

The buns are from Marks and Spencer. They do good bun.

18 years ago
Reply to  Lee

Thinking of wiseassed comment about buns. Er, never mind.
*whispering* DSH didn’t rock my world, not to worry about not opening that door IMHO /whispering

Just saying …

Have a fabu vacation. With lots of buns. And stuff.

Lee
18 years ago
Reply to  Divalano

Thanks Diva! I’m wishing you pleasantly spiced buns too.:d

Anne
18 years ago

Just to share email from DSH… mostly bath products and creams but also 10% off codes (to use on entire order so I think it would count for fragrance samples too).

OUR FIRST ANNUAL SPRING CLEANING SALE Wow-ee! We’re ripe and ready to get a jump-start on Spring cleaning with our first annual Bath and Body sale! We’ve chosen TONS of customer favorite bath & body products (in your favorite scents and from almost all of our many collections) to put on sale at 10-60% off! And just to make it all the sweeter, you can use member codes MUA, POL and PAM to take an additional 10% off your entire order! This is your chance to treat yourself to some of the amazing DSH bath and body products you’ve been thinking about…and get them at a great savings. You can check out everything on SALE on the SPECIALS PAGE(s). The link to get you there is located at the top right hand corner of any page inside the site. The sale goes on until March 30, 2008, so don’t let April showers find you without your favorite DSH washes, lotions, liquid powders and cremes!

:)>-

Louise
18 years ago

Agree on Cocoon-and I love Borneo, various mixtures of patch and choco, even Angel on the right person. But Cocoon is toooo sweet.

Thanks for the help addressing my DSH problem-I just don’t know where to start. I’ve tried a few, and none have worked, but mostly it’s the variety that daunts me….but that Blond Suede sounds like a winner, and Mahjoun, and Sienna, and The Afternoon, and, and, and…

Maria
18 years ago
Reply to  March

Several of the DSH do last on me. I think the Sienna less so, but I may be misremembering.

18 years ago

Oh gosh, now I feel sorta, kinda, almost famous :d

I’m also a big fan of The Afternoon but don’t know if you’d like it or not. It’s a nice soft green that almost floats above you like a cloud on a warm early summer day (boy…shoulda entered that Prix Eau Faux contest with that one!) Now that you’ve got me thinking about DSH again, I also had to place a sample order that I’m really looking forward to. Particularly Hemlock, because who wouldn’t want to smell like hemlock, huh?

Those Kenzo bottles are insanely cute, too bad I can’t stand what they hold :((

18 years ago
Reply to  March

It’s the wood. I have to be somewhat careful with woody notes and this is apparently one that has sharp teeth for me. Cherry blossom, rice, tea, etc? Forget about it – all wood. And not just a nice soft wood, nooooo, it feels like it’s about 300 degrees and I’m gonna spontaneously combust any second.

18 years ago
Reply to  Gail S

That Green scent (The Afternoon) sounds like a sampler and I love your description! – I’m looking for a new green to replace Calyx, which is coming over a bit harsh. I also like the name, being particularly fond of summer afternoons.

18 years ago
Reply to  Musette

It’s definitely worth sampling! Very pretty, soft green scent 😡

Maria
18 years ago

I’m with you on comfort scents. I was the happy winner of Patty’s DSH drawing, so I got to try some of the scents on your to-try list. I wore Tamarind/Paprika on New Year’s Day. On the spur of the moment we decided to extend a short trip into one that took us to Big Sur and a restaurant with a perfect view of a Pacific sunset. The fragrance was suitable for the festive occasion, but would have been fine at home too. Its fruitiness is a nice mellow one that blends well with the rest of the scent. It’s a limited edition, keep in mind.

Piment/Chocolat is probably my favorite DSH. The hot spice of it contrasts beautifully with the chocolate. Lumiere is wonderful–comfort itself. I should put some on soon. Poivre is a nice carnation scent, but to me Poivre means Caron.

Has anyone tried Hinoki? The notes call out my name.

Have you tried Sonoma Scent Studio Opal? That’s a soft “skin” scent that I like to wear to bed. I only have a sample or I’d send you some.

Louise
18 years ago
Reply to  March

Your guinea pig/pet, yet again 😕

Sadly, the CDG Hinoki disappears in a nano on me-unlike most CDGs (just bought their Carnation-yum!)

18 years ago

I spent a wicked week one evening trailing my pirogue through the backwaters of the dense, dark, and divine waterways of DSH.
Cimabue was different than I expected–I expected ancient walls, mist, incense, because of the name(Cimabue was the mentor of the first great Renaissance painter, Giotto). Not at all. It is rich, even, well-blended pure comfort scent of bitter orange, bergamot, nutmeg, beeswax, sandalwood, vanilla and a zillion other things that are wonderful. On the drydown, I get a wiff of something deeper, maybe ciste, but it is never, ever anything else than old world elegant.

Gingembre has all the notes you’d expect to like–pepper, benzoin, landanum. My skin, however, picks up the part of jasmine I don’t get along with and stokes it up with ambrette. So on my skin (which is bizarre, I know) I get ginger root left in a cardboard box next to a dead jasmine corsage. Which is why I like Fire Opal, a orange/spice mix that blooms on me.

And for Spring, or in an office that doesn’t love perfumes, I like Les Petites, with it’s camomile, linden and rose wash. I’m not a fan of rose, but a DSH rose is always touched with magic. And Linden can be tricky, but here is simply Spring in a waft of fresh blossoms on a tree.

18 years ago
Reply to  March

When I finished writing the post, I fell off the edge of the earth into DSH again, and ordered more samples–this time the cooler ones. It’s heating up here, so Cimabue is moving into the “overheated’ zone, I was browsing some lighter ones, and missed Afternoon. I LOVE green scents, and with a little spice or a bit of cream I can be had. I love Hinoki (mentioned below), but it vanishes on me, too.

18 years ago
Reply to  March

Oh, I’m glad you liked La Fete Nouvelle. I ordered a sample of that one–along with about a gazillion others. The UPS truck will arrive looking like a Low Rider. Fete was to sooth my ruffled feelings over a bottle of L’Artisan’s Jour du Fete I ordered, a huge favorite of mine several years ago. They reformulated it into some vapid almond water. They should really have to tell you or change the label if they reformulate. I’m hoping I can find a scent that can stand up to the industrial-size heat we get here in the summer. I (blasphemy!) am about citrused out.

18 years ago
Reply to  QuinnCreative

QC –

Have you tried Vent Vert? I would recommend Vacances but it’s stupid-hard to find, costs the earth when you do…and there’s often this round, lush Patou-y note that surfaces in extreme heat – it can become a little too lush and oily for me then…but the new Vent Vert (which can’t hold a candle to the original, alas) is pretty nice. Very green and crisp. Haven’t been on the board long enough to sort out everyone’s preferences so forgive me if I’m erring on the ‘green’ suggestion.

My other possible new BFF for summer (maybe – we’ll see when it hits 90!) is L’Eau d’Hiver….