Eau de Magnolia by Carlos Benaim: Frederic Malle 2014

Hi Crew, Magnolia is such a beautiful scent and while I often enjoyed the fragrances made that nod to magnolia I’d never smelled the Magnolia Grandiflora until this year. My mates have two trees in their front yard but for some reason I’d never noticed them flowering until we went to dinner the other night and there were two perfect blooms in the center of the table and the smell was intoxicating, a couple of times I lost track of the conversation because my mind was totally immersed in trying to get more scent from them to waft towards me, HA! It was kind of nerdy. So it was with much excitement that I searched out Eau de Magnolia….

Eau de Magnolia by Carlos Benaim for Frederic Malle 2014

Eau De Magnolia Frederic Malle FragranticaPhoto Stolen Fragrantica

Fragrantica gives these featured accords:
Top: Calabrian bergamot
Heart: Magnolia, vetiver, patchouli
Base: Cedar, moss, amber

Carlos Benaim is not a perfumer who is regularly in the spotlight, which is strange because he has been the mastermind behind loads of blockbuster fragrances: BVLGARI Jasmine Noir, CK Eternity Men, Euphoria Women and Man, Carolina Herrera, DIOR Pure Poison, Elizabeth Arden Red Door, Ralph Laurent Polo, Victor & Rolf Flowerbomb and Eau Mega are just a few of this man’s incredible output.

Below are pictures of the flower from my friends bush, yes I asked to steal one after dinner, they are taken same time 3 nights in a row.

Patrick & Wayne Magnolia 2015b

So if you are expecting Eau de Magnolia to be a completely photo realistic scent copy of a magnolia grandiflora then you will be sadly let down, so what you have to expect is an artists rendering of a magnolia. Here the structure of the journey is laid out in bright and sizzling citrus to open that lasts well into the heart and even hints still remain in the base.

Magnolia P&W Day 2

Eau de Magnolia’s floral heart is dewy and cool, a fresh and refreshing take on the big white floral that is neither big nor particularly floral. More earthy and wet, but not wet earth, imagine digging your healthy compost heap on a sea bluff in an early spring morning just as you start to warm through in the thin warmth of the sun.In real life the dying magnolia goes brown and gets an incredibly vegetal muskiness, murky and deep.

Magnolia P&W Day 3

End it all with a still lightly sparkling citrus/moss/patchouli warmed in amber. The magnolia in my kitchen has an incredibly animal smell now, decay and bad breath. Still strangely alluring but nothing like Eau de Magnolia.

Further reading: Olfactoria’s Travels and Australian Perfume Junkies
Frederic Malle has €34/10ml
Surrender To Chance has samples starting at $7.60/ml

If you liked this then jump on over to AustralianPerfumeJunkies too, there’s always something fun going on over there. We love visitors.

Which Malle is your favourite? Which magnolia has tickled your fancy?
Portia xx

0 0 votes
Article Rating
24 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
11 years ago

Thanks for the advice and sharing.

aekval
11 years ago

Selling original perfumes all brands, very special prices.
http://www.niatti.com

Michele42
11 years ago

I had no idea the Magnolia flower goes brown and dies off so quickly. Great review…I think I’ll need to give this Malle a sniff!

Tara C
11 years ago

My favorite is the Aqua di Parma Magnolia Nobile, but the FM is nice too. Love the photos!

Ellen
11 years ago

The Magnolia Grandiflora blooms where I live in great profusion, and I love them. I’d like to know if there is a fragrance out there that is just that, not a take on the flower, but the actual flower before it turns brown. Any suggestions?

Kathleen
11 years ago
Reply to  Ellen

Ellen, Maitre Parfumeu et Gantier did a beautiful one. Of course, it is discontinued. You can get a decant at the link below. I find it very true. Lemony sweet, with that touch of tobacco. I love it.

http://theposhpeasant.com/item_637/Maitre-Parfumeur-et-Gantier-Magnolia-Pourpre.htm

Ellen
11 years ago
Reply to  Kathleen

Thank you. I’m going to try it. The Magnoia Grandiflora Michel was as close as I’ve come to the real thing, so we’ll see.

11 years ago

I just wanted to say, those are gorgeous pics, brightened up my morning considerably. Eau de Magnolia is one of my favorites in the FM line even if it isn’t magnolia. It just smells good, doesn’t it?

Kathleen
11 years ago

Hey Portia! So correct me if I am wrong. “An artist’s rendering of a magnolia” translates to, nothing at all like the flower, and he should have called it something different? You know what was a really fab magnolia, and not an artist’s rendering of the flower? MPG Magnolia Pourpre. Beautiful stuff. Of course, discontinued. It had all the nuances of the magnolia. A lemony sweetness, with that slight touch of tobacco. Search this out, if you love magnolia

Kandice
11 years ago

Glad to see your review. This is the only FM I’ve tried and it’s one of my favorite perfumes. Like Ann, I do get some real magnolia scent from this perfume. Also like Ann, I love Grandiflora’s Magnolia Michel. (Feel better soon Ann!). Since I also love orange blossom, I’m looking forward to the new FM Cologne Indelibile as well.

Ann
11 years ago
Reply to  Kandice

Thanks, Kandice!

Ann
11 years ago

Whoo-hoo, Portia! When I saw your post this morning, I nearly jumped up and down! This has been a fave of mine since last summer, where I wore it often as a great heat-buster. And if we keep warming up around here (mid 90s next week — yikes!), I’ll be pulling this out often. Funny, on my skin, for a little while in the middle, I do get a fairly realistic wash of magnolia.
Other magnolias I enjoy are Acqua di Parma Magnolia Nobile and both of the Magnolia Grandifloras (although I think I prefer Michel’s just a wee bit more). Thanks again for a real day-brightener — I hope to get to sniffing again this week after a nasty bout of bronchitis.

Ann
11 years ago
Reply to  Portia

Thanks — I’m working on it. Hope to be sniffing again soon.

11 years ago

Beautiful vase too.

11 years ago

Love the compost heap on the sea bluff on a spring morning! You come up with the best and most imaginative comparisons Portia. Eau de Magnolia is indeed cool and dewy, perfect for hot weather.

Fab time lapse pics. Thanks for the link love.

Right now I love Cologne Indelebile from Frederic Malle – yummy orange blossom.