I had another fragrance post written up for today, but when Portia gave such an evocative, hilarious review of Creed Carmina on Thursday, well. You know what happened, right? I put on my sunhat and my walking shoes and toddled on over to our local Cos Bar, which carries Creed, and where they did indeed have Carmina in stock.
So this is partly my take on Carmina, but really it’s more about the thought process, i.e., what is wrong with us? Suppose, for instance, that we were all wine aficionados and this was a wine blog called, I dunno, Wine Nerds or Wine Me Up. If Portia got on here and described quaffing a random merlot as “like eating a whole handful of red confectionary snakes … as if your mouth is so full of over sweetened jellied sugar that everything else in life is put on hold till you chomp your way through it all,” would you rush to Total Wine to try it out for yourself? Probably not. Another example: I love Trader Joe’s, but if/when online reviewers describe their new frozen dumplings as “like eating mounds of soggy toilet paper,” my first thought isn’t oh man I gotta check that out!
But something about fragrance brings out this illogical, contrarian impulse. Right? It’s not just me? (I KNOW it’s not just me.) If it’s weird enough or provocative or interesting enough and not merely dreadful like another-fruity-amber from Sephora, well … I want what you’re having, you know? I want to sniff for myself, even if that road leads to Mugler’s Human Existence or ELdO Secretions Magnifique.
I’m so not a Creed girlie, I’ve never liked one enough to spring for even a decant, although I’ve sniffed them randomly over the years. But how could I resist the siren call of “a fabulously disgusting monolith” per Portia? (Portia, they really should hire you to write their copy.) Here’s the notes again so you don’t have to look them up: Black Cherry, Saffron, Pink Pepper, Rose de Mai, Violet, Cashmere Wood, Peony, Frankincense, Myrrh, Amber, Musk. Honestly? Those notes sound pretty darn good to me right off the bat, I like cherry (helloooo, Poison!) and saffron as well. After sniffing it on a card, I had them make me up a sample so I could put it on when I knew I wouldn’t be doing anything fragrance-prohibited.
Annnnnnnd?!? Well, yes, it’s kind of a lot. A lot of white musk and candy floss right off the bat, I don’t get cherry or pink pepper, and the saffron’s in there smelling a bit like suede. (Apologies to all you saffron-haters.) Honestly I’m not sure I ever get anything I’d describe as “floral” from this, much less peony and rose, although maybe some candied violets? “Candied” would be a good word for this journey overall. It does settle down after about an hour, a smaller pink cloud with a bare hint of Play-doh and a sueded amber-woods-musk base, plus a wee dollop of something buttery. It does smell expensively niche (which it should at $465 a bottle) rather than a dime-store sugar overload.
Would I buy this? No, not at full retail, although I might spring for a decant. The bottle is every bit as gorgeous IRL, if you are curious. Would I wear this if I had it? Yes, strategically and with some forethought, because Portia’s right, it’s not going anywhere for quite awhile. It’s kind of the same niche as Fracas – a huge pink cloud of a fragrance, although more musk and less sweet to my nose. They don’t smell the same, but they wear similarly. I like it, especially the pillowy drydown. Honestly, I think I like it more than any of the other Creeds I’ve tried. It’s pretty widely available online at various price points, although exercise caution with resellers because there are fakes on Shein.
Are you a perverse perfume person? (Say that three times fast.) Will you actively search out, or at least keep an eye peeled for, a fragrance just because it sounds so outlandish?
cover image via Pexels





