Two freezing cold days last week. Bright and clear, with hard frosts. Now, we’re back to rain and a bit warmer. The fig has lost all its leaves. The last roses wilted and I cut everything back. Definitely hunkering down and waiting to hibernate.
Somewhere within time recently it occurred to me that I might need to buy a backup of Mitsouko extract. *My current bottle (see pic) is very low. It’s also quite old in the scheme of things. At least 25 years old but probably older.

I got it in a swap with someone from the Makeup Alley fragrance board when that place was a treasure trove of swaps; unusual, hard to find samples; hilarity, and serious knowledgeable perfumistas. The current price for a 50ml bottle of extrait is £315 (some places have it on discount to £225-ish – I don’t know why as I can’t imagine Guerlain would be stupid enough to discontinue it). I don’t know what the bottle price was back 25 years but I imagine it was around £150 or less.
I can’t recall what I offered in return. All that stays with me is a woman who felt that this iteration of Mitsouko didn’t work on her and someone else should enjoy her bottle. Which I very much have. It was probably three-quarters or more full when I got it. This was my second bottle of extract, the first being a 15ml. Cute (I hate that word), isn’t it… It lives on my dresser along with pics and miscellaneous objects.

In any case, I was thinking about backups within the scheme of the UK government saying we should have a cache of non-perishable foods and water to cover three days. That got me thinking about having backups of one or two bottles if it got much more difficult to access them.
I have a mostly full bottle of Shalimar extract plus a pretty full bottle of EdT (apparently those are the ones one should have, with the EdP being not all that). I have backups of the discontinued Theo Fennell Scent. So, my mind turned to Mitsouko. In the process it occurred to me that I’d never smelled anything but the extract. No EdP, no EdT. A couple of things occurred to me.
First, I thought I should try another iteration. So, I bought an EdP sample (I couldn’t find any EdT samples). Second, I figured if I was doing that I might as well parlay that into a side by side post. Just for the sake of it. And three, I went looking for the current price of an ounce/50ml bottle of extrait and discovered it’s pricey but not insane, and it’s hard to get in the UK (as noted above). So, the search goes on the to do list for when I am next in Paris, which hopefully will be spring of next year. I’ve never visited the main Guerlain shop and this is a good excuse.
Mitsouko. 1919. Fruity chypre by Jacques Guerlain. Avant Garde. Bergamot, citruses, jasmine, rose, peach, ylang-ylang, rose, lilac, oakmoss, spices, cinnamon, vetiver and amber. I’m sure there’s anise in the mix or maybe carnation that doesn’t get talked about.
First, the EdP. I expect this is a very recent iteration. It is most certainly Mitsouko. But, on me, it is very heavy on the anise/pepper/carnation note first go-round. Very. I get the citrus up top. Don’t get as much peach as the extrait. Second try much more Mitsouko unfolding. Heavier on flowers and oakmoss much more present. Smooth, with good longevity.
On to the extrait. Guerlain now groups these fragrances under the Les Légendaires label.
As noted, this is at least 25 years old, and probably more towards 30. Out of the bottle the opening for the first 5 seconds is sour but then, after that … it’s glorious. Boy, is it great. I pity all those people who denigrate ‘old lady’ scents. But, more for the rest of us.
Sure, there’s a bit of anise/pepper/carnation in this but mostly it’s just so well balanced: a whisper of citrus, a breeze of pepper, that peach (ahhhh), a bouquet of flowers (I think jasmine is the most prominent), and then smoothing into a melange of sharp oakmoss, a bit more of that carnation/pepper, amber to anchor things.
When I first got this it lasted forever on my skin. Now, it’s still got a decent run even after all those years in the bottle.
I know some people find chypres, and Mitsouko in particular, hard work. I remember when I first got this it’s all I wore for a while. I just felt so lucky to have this juice even if it didn’t get compliments like I did for some of my more accessible, more amber-sweet-woody perfumes.
In the end from this experience, I feel no need to own more than the extrait, even though the EdP is quite good. But, having said that, I don’t know what the current iteration smells like. Will hopefully sort that next year – and I do hope it’s near enough to what I have to result in a bottle coming home with me.
Pics: mine, pexels